Finding the perfect sheet set for your bed can be a challenge. Everyone wants soft, breathable sheets for a comfortable night’s sleep, but too often soft sheets tear easily and don’t last very long.
If you are tired of replacing your flimsy bed sheets and want a set of durable, tear-proof sheets that are also comfortable, keep reading. Sleep Detectives has found six great options for tear-proof bedding that won’t disappoint.
What are the Most Durable Tear Proof Bedding Sets?
- Our Top Pick: Mellanni Luxury Hotel Sheet Set
- The Runner Up: Bedsure Bamboo Cooling Sheets
- The Eco-Friendly Option: LuxClub Eco-Friendly Bamboo Sheets
- Eddie Bauer Flannel Collection
- Treat Yourself: Thread Spread Pure Egyptian Cotton Sheets
- The Budget Option: Sonoro Kate Microfiber Sheet Set
Our Top Pick: Mellanni Luxury Hotel Sheet Set
Review of the Mellanni Luxury Hotel Sheets
Here's our review of the Mellanni Luxury Hotel Sheets. We based our review on durability, softness, value, comfort, and customer satisfaction. Here are the results:
- 1800 brushed microfiber material is strong to prevent tearing
- Breathable and moisture wicking
- Silky soft
- Easy care- fade, stain, shrink and wrinkle resistant
- Money back guarantee
- Deep pockets may be too large for a standard mattress
- Microfiber material, not cotton
Why Choose the Mellanni Sheet Set?
The Mellanni Hotel Luxury Sheet Set is the softest sheet set I have ever bought and I was pleasantly surprised at how well constructed they were. The high-quality brushed microfiber material is durable and tear-resistant.
One nice feature of these sheets is that the bottom sheet has elastic all the way around, not just at the corners. This makes the bottom sheet stay on your mattress securely and you spend less time pulling at your sheets risking tears and damage.
As someone who usually likes cotton sheets, I was hesitant to try microfiber, but these sheets were very breathable and felt more luxurious than some 100% cotton sheets I have had in the past.
- Good Housekeeping Best Bedding Award Winner - On the hunt for Christmas gift ideas? Tried, tested, & named "Buttery Budget Buy" in 2023. Mellanni's flagship 4-piece, queen size sheet set - top sheet 102"x90", fitted sheet 80"x60", & 2 envelope style pillow cases 20"x30" - offers ultra-soft bedding at an affordable price.
- Temperature Regulating - Moisture-wicking, breathable, & silky to the touch. Mellanni double-brushed microfiber is cozy or cooling, depending on the season. Our lightweight sheet set is ideal for all sleepers, including those with sensitive skin.
Available Sizes and Options
The Mellanni Sheets come in a large variety of size and color options so you will have no problem finding the set that fits your bed and your style.
You can choose from all the standard bed sizes from Twin to California King. They even offer Twin XL for dorm rooms, Short Queen for RV beds, and a Split King set.
While these sheets already fit mattresses up to 16” deep, Mellanni also features extra deep pocket options for those who have extra thick mattresses.
You don’t have to worry about finding a color that matches your décor because these sheets come in over 40 different color and pattern options. I purchased the Madison Purple floral pattern, and the actual sheets are true to the color and style pictured.
Durable and Hassle-Free Care
I like to wash my sheets at least once a week. With pets and kids, my sheets experience a lot of wear and tear, so they need to be durable. The Mellanni sheets not only withstand frequent washes, but they actually get softer over time.
These sheets are also fade, stain, shrink, and wrinkle resistant. They are extremely durable despite being soft and feeling luxurious.
If you aren’t happy with your sheets, Mellanni provides customers with a Lifetime Promise. You can return your sheets at any time for any reason with no questions asked. With this kind of guarantee, you have nothing to lose by giving these sheets a try.
The Runner Up: Bedsure Bamboo Cooling Sheets
If you aren’t crazy about microfiber sheets but still want a durable bedding option, bamboo sheets may be the option for you. The Bedsure Bamboo Cooling Sheets are perfect for hot sleepers who are looking for a strong set of tear-proof sheets.
Bamboo viscose is a strong material but feels soft, so it is ideal for tear-proof sheets. These sheets will stand up to everyday wear and frequent washes.
- Silky Soft: Bedsure Queen Sheet Set are made from rayon derived from bamboo with a unique twill weave, making it stronger than cotton and smooth like silk. Sleep like you're on a cloud with our comfy bed sheets.
- Cool & Dry All Night: Experience the ultimate comfort and luxury with these sheets set. Made from rayon derived from bamboo, these cooling sheets are moisture-wicking, breathable, and thermoregulating, keeping you refreshed all year round.
Great for Sensitive Skin
The Bedsure Bamboo sheets are a great option if you have sensitive skin. These sheets are OEKO TEX certified so you can rest assured that they are healthy, eco-friendly, and don’t contain any harmful materials.
Pros of the Bedsure Sheets:
- Made from 100% organic viscose from bamboo
- Moisture wicking and naturally cooling
- Deep pockets for thick mattresses
Cons of the Bedsure Sheets:
The only negative I found with these sheets is that they tend to stain easily. If you have oily skin or use moisturizers before bed you may see some discoloration on your sheets in the morning.
If oily skin has been an issue you should consider investing in a quality pillow protector. Check out these options for the Best Pillow Protectors for Oily Skin.
The Eco-Friendly Option: LuxClub Eco-Friendly Bamboo Sheets
If you are a fan of bamboo sheets, the Lux Club Eco-Friendly Bamboo Sheets are our second bamboo option. Bamboo sheets are soft, yet durable so they make great options for tear-proof bedding.
7 used from $25.79
- LUXURY BEDDING: Includes 1 fitted Sheet, 1 flat Sheet and 4 pillowcases. Our LuxClub 6 pc sheets set for queen size bed Sheets are crafted from a blend of 80% microfiber and 20% rayon made from bamboo, offer a more luxurious and comfortable bedding experience than even the finest Egyptian cotton sheets and pillowcases. With double-brushed polyester microfiber, these queen sheets outperform 100% cotton for softness and breathability.
Size and Color Options
I love the variety of colors that LuxClub offers for this sheet set. There are over 40 vibrant and fun color options to match any bedroom in your home. I picked the Medallion Gold set for my guest bedroom and the color is just as bright in person as in the pictures. These sheets also come in all standard sizes and fit mattresses up to 18 inches deep.
How Luxurious Are LuxClub Sheets?
The LuxClub bamboo sheet set is made of bamboo viscose blended with microfiber for extra softness and durability. The blend between bamboo and microfiber will make these sheets stronger than just bamboo sheets alone. These sheets won’t tear or pill with frequent use.
With these sheets, you will enjoy the following features:
- Superior breathability
- Wrinkle resistant
- Anti-pill and fade resistant for longevity
- Cooling and temperature regulating
- Eco-friendly and sourced from sensible suppliers
LuxClub also offers a lifetime guarantee so if these sheets don’t prove to be strong and tear-proof, you can return them at any time.
For Extra Warmth: Eddie Bauer Flannel Collection
In the cold winter months, there is nothing better than a thick warm set of flannel sheets. These Eddie Bauer Flannel Collection sheets are the perfect tear-proof option.
With 30 cute winter-themed patterns to choose from, the Eddie Bauer flannel sheets will have you ready and excited for the colder months.
2 used from $44.17
- SHEET FABRIC: Made from 100% Cotton Flannel
- STYLE & TOUCH: Brushed three times for extra softness and coziness; Perfect for warm sleepers. This Eddie Bauer Montlake Plaid flannel sheet set features a red and khaki plaid design
- DEEP POCKET & SECURE FIT: Set includes a fully elastic fitted sheet- Premium elastic installed all-around to keep the fitted sheet in place; DEEP POCKET: 15" fitted sheet pocket depth (12" for twin sizes) - Fitted sheet fits mattress up to 18" (Up to 15" for Twin sizes); Pillowcase. This Eddie Bauer Montlake Plaid flannel sheet set features a red and khaki plaid design
Features of the Eddie Bauer Flannel Bedding
My favorite feature of these sheets is that they are 100% cotton flannel. Flannel is a naturally stronger material because it is thick and tightly woven to create extra warmth. This means you know these sheets will be strong, durable, tear-proof, and keep you warm all season long.
These flannel sheets have a raised surface and are triple brushed for extra softness.
Other features include:
- Woven cotton yarns
- Fully elasticized fitted sheet to prevent slipping
- Machine washable for easy care
Cons of the Flannel Collection
The only issue with flannel sheets is that they are very warm. While this is perfect for winter and in colder climates, unless you are a very cold sleeper, these are not year-round sheets. You will need to buy another set of different sheets for warmer temperatures.
Treat Yourself: Thread Spread Pure Egyptian Cotton Sheets
If you’re looking to splurge on a set of high-quality and durable sheets, look no further than Thread Spread’s Pure Egyptian Cotton Sheets. Egyptian cotton is famous for being the most luxurious material for sheets and as an added bonus, it is also a very strong material for added durability.
- Top Quality Egyptian Cotton Queen Sheets Set: Our Silver, queen sheets deep pocket are as soft as a cloud and will help to provide you with a more restful night’s sleep. These deep pocket sheets queen size sets made from specially compacted yarns made from 100% long staple cotton are Standard 100 by OEKO-TEX ensuring you of thread count and performance.
- 1000 Thread Count, Deep Pocket Queen Sheets (4 Piece Set): These luxurious, 1000 thread count queen sheet sets come with a flat sheet (90” x 102”), a deep fitted sheets queen size (60” x 80” + 16") with an all-around elastic that fits an 16” deep mattress, & a pair of standard size 21” x 32” pillowcases.
About the Material
Thread Spread’s sheets are made from 100% extra-long staple cotton in a sateen weave. They are 1000 thread count so they are extra soft and luxurious, but also very strong.
Thread count refers to the number of threads in one square inch of the fabric. The higher the thread count, the more quality material. Sheets that are 1000 thread count are very durable and essentially tear-proof.
These Egyptian Cotton sheets are anti-pilling and fade resistant so they will last a long time even with frequent washes.
Pros of the Egyptian Cotton Sheet Set
- Cooling and lightweight
- 1000 thread count for softness and durability
- Great for all seasons
- OEKO TEX certified and free from harmful materials
- Extra deep pockets
- Sustainably sourced and produced
Cons of the Egyptian Cotton Sheet Set
- Extra care must be taken when washing and drying
The Budget Option: Sonoro Kate Microfiber Sheet Set
For shoppers who don’t want to spend an arm and a leg but still want durable, tear-proof bedding, check out the Sonoro Kate Microfiber Sheet Set. These sheets are extra soft and comfortable and are made from 1800 series ultra-soft double-brushed microfiber fabric.
2 used from $21.93
- EXTRA DEEP POCKET SHEETS - These bed sheets are for very deep pocket mattresses. They fit any mattress with pockets that are 18, 20, 21, 22 and 24 inches deep mattresses.
- Queen Size Luxury 4pc Bed Sheets Set - 1 flat sheet 90"x102", 1 fitted sheet 60"x80"x21"（has elastic so it can stretch）,2 pillowcases 20"x30".Deep pockets that fit mattresses up to 18"-24" deep with elastic around the fitted sheet.
I love that these sheets are durable and easy to care for. The 1800 microfiber thread count makes them well constructed and resistant to tearing. They are machine washable and can be dried quickly on a tumble setting.
Unlike some other microfiber sheet sets I have tried, the Sonoro Kate sheets are very breathable and didn’t make me sweat at night.
The Sonoro Kate Microfiber Sheet Set is a great way to upgrade your sheets to a durable tear-proof option without breaking the bank.
For more microfiber sheet options on a budget, check out our Bare Home Bed Sheet Review!